Thursday, April 07, 2005

Downtown Losing It's Soul?

Yesterday a news story on Channel 7, indicated that the First Methodist Church on Pineapple was considering a developer's offer to buy the church property and transform it into a massive retail area in the Orange to Pineapple area.

Butch Isaac has made an offer that includes enough cash to retire the church's debt, purchase a suburban location (near Tuttle & University), build a new sanctuary and office/class room space and have money left over.

First Methodist has been part of downtown Sarasota for 108 years, providing a place where visitors and members can practice their faith. The programs that First Methodist provides have been a vital thread in the Sarasota fabric. Now, however, the "market" is speaking. Will the "market" speak loud enough to chase this Soul of Sarasota to the suburbs?

First Methodist leaders and members will make their decision on April 24. Stay tuned.

The mantra of "let the market forces decide" may not be the best decision for Sarasota. Does Sarasota really need retail at the expense of a major downtown church?

We trust the members of First Methodist will make a good decision. They are in a tough postion having to deal now with very difficult decisions as change works its way through our society. We recognize that what is best for First Methodist may not match the views of others in Sarasota. We do wish them the best in whichever future path they choose.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Dick...I was on Fifth Avenue after Christmas and walked around the area with new eyes. I had forgotten how many churches are on Fifth near 53rd Street. Mostly early 1900s...a Presbyterian, a Methodist, St. Patrick's, etc.The more dense the city becomes, the more these sanctuaries are needed. Also, on Fifth, some buildings are only three stories high.Two hotels in the area were both circa 1904...the Penisular and the St. Regis.All great cities enjoy diversity.